Chemical and Process Engineering Comparison

Absorption vs Adsorption: Differences

Absorption vs Adsorption: Differences: featured diagram
Short answer

In absorption vs adsorption, absorption is the uptake of a substance into the whole volume of another phase, such as a gas dissolving into a liquid solvent. Adsorption is the accumulation of molecules on the surface of a solid or liquid, usually inside porous solids. Absorption is a bulk process; adsorption is a surface process.

The two words differ by one letter, and both remove a component from a gas or liquid stream, so they are easy to confuse. The absorption vs adsorption distinction matters because it decides the equipment, the equilibrium model, the way the separating agent is regenerated and the scale at which each process makes sense. This article compares them side by side, then works a Langmuir isotherm example.

What absorption and adsorption mean

IUPAC defines absorption as a process in which one material (the absorbate) is retained by another (the absorbent) and penetrates its bulk. In chemical engineering the usual case is gas absorption: a soluble gas such as ammonia, carbon dioxide or hydrogen sulphide passes into a liquid solvent. The solute spreads through the liquid by diffusion and mixing until it reaches its solubility limit.

Adsorption is the enrichment of one or more components at an interface. The solid is the adsorbent, and the molecules held on it are the adsorbate. Industrial adsorbents such as activated carbon, silica gel, activated alumina and zeolites are highly porous, so almost all of their surface lies inside the pores. IUPAC classifies pores as micropores (below 2 nm wide), mesopores (2 to 50 nm) and macropores (above 50 nm).

AbsorptionAdsorptionAbsorber columnGasLiquid solventGas or liquidSolid adsorbentSolute dissolves into thewhole liquid volumeSolute collects as a layeron the solid surfaceSolvent inClean gas outGas inRich solvent outLiquid downGas up
Absorption takes solute into the bulk of the liquid; adsorption holds it on the solid surface. In a counter-current absorber the gas rises through the packing while the solvent flows down.
Download diagram (WebP)

Absorption vs adsorption: comparison table

FeatureAbsorptionAdsorption
Where the solute goesInto the bulk of the absorbentOnto the surface of the adsorbent
Separating agentLiquid solvent (water, amines, oils)Porous solid (activated carbon, zeolites, silica gel, activated alumina)
NatureBulk phenomenon, solute distributed through volumeSurface phenomenon, capacity set by surface area
Equilibrium modelHenry’s law for dilute physical absorptionAdsorption isotherms such as Langmuir and Freundlich
Heat effectHeat of solution, plus heat of reaction in chemical absorptionExothermic; chemisorption releases more heat than physisorption
Typical operationContinuous, steady state counter-current columnCyclic fixed beds, adsorb then regenerate
RegenerationStripping or distillation of the rich solventTemperature swing, pressure swing or purge, or replacement
Best suited toLarge gas flows with moderate to high solute contentLow concentrations, deep purification, drying
Typical equipmentPacked or tray absorber with a stripperFixed bed adsorbers in pairs or sets

Differences explained

Equilibrium

For dilute physical absorption, equilibrium follows Henry’s law: the partial pressure of the solute over the liquid is proportional to its mole fraction in the liquid. Solubility rises as temperature falls and as pressure rises, which is why absorbers run cool and often at elevated pressure.

Adsorption equilibrium is described by an isotherm, the loading on the solid at a fixed temperature as a function of fluid concentration or pressure. The Langmuir isotherm assumes a uniform surface, one molecule per site, a single layer and no interaction between adsorbed molecules. At low pressure it reduces to a straight line, similar to Henry’s law. At high pressure the loading levels off at the monolayer capacity, because the surface is full. A liquid can keep dissolving solute up to its solubility limit, but a surface has a fixed number of sites.

Mass transfer

In absorption, the solute crosses a gas film and a liquid film at the interface, as described by the two film theory. Column packing or trays create a large gas and liquid contact area. In adsorption the solute travels from the bulk fluid to the outer surface of the particle, then diffuses into the pores before attaching to the wall. In a fixed bed this creates a mass transfer zone that moves down the bed. When it reaches the outlet, the solute concentration rises, giving the breakthrough curve, and the bed must be switched and regenerated.

Physical and chemical uptake

Both processes have a physical and a chemical form. Physical absorption dissolves the gas without reaction, while chemical absorption uses a reactive solvent, such as aqueous amines for carbon dioxide and hydrogen sulphide, which raises capacity at low partial pressures. Likewise, physisorption relies on van der Waals forces and is readily reversed, while chemisorption forms surface bonds and is limited to a monolayer.

Regeneration and operation

An absorber usually runs continuously. The rich solvent goes to a stripper, where heat, steam or reduced pressure releases the solute, and the lean solvent returns to the top of the absorber. Adsorbers are batch units in a cyclic process. Temperature swing adsorption heats the bed to release the adsorbate, while pressure swing adsorption lowers the pressure. Two or more beds alternate so that one adsorbs while another regenerates.

Equations for absorption and adsorption

Henry’s law for a dilute solute A:

pA=H xAp_A = H\,x_A

Langmuir isotherm and fractional coverage:

q=qmKp1+Kpθ=qqmq = \frac{q_m K p}{1 + K p} \qquad \theta = \frac{q}{q_m}

Solute balance for a counter-current absorber on a solute free basis, with Y the gas phase and X the liquid phase mole ratio, subscript 1 at the bottom and 2 at the top:

Gs (Y1−Y2)=Ls (X1−X2)G_s\,(Y_1 - Y_2) = L_s\,(X_1 - X_2)
Worked example
Given
A gas adsorbs on an activated carbon that follows the Langmuir isotherm with monolayer capacity q_m = 4.0 mol/kg and constant K = 0.25 kPa⁻¹ at the operating temperature. The solute partial pressure in the feed is 12 kPa. The bed must hold 45 mol of solute per cycle.
Find
The equilibrium loading, the fractional coverage, the minimum mass of carbon, and the gain in loading if the partial pressure were doubled.
Assumptions
Isothermal bed; Langmuir model valid; the whole bed reaches equilibrium with the feed (no mass transfer zone left unused); no competing adsorbates.
Solution
K p = 0.25 × 12 = 3.0
θ = 3.0 ÷ (1 + 3.0) = 0.75
q = 4.0 × 0.75 = 3.0 mol/kg
Carbon mass = 45 ÷ 3.0 = 15 kg
At 24 kPa: K p = 6.0, θ = 6.0 ÷ 7.0 = 0.857, q = 3.43 mol/kg, a rise of about 14 percent
Answer
Loading 3.0 mol/kg at 75 percent coverage, so at least 15 kg of carbon is needed. Doubling the partial pressure raises loading by only about 14 percent, because the surface is close to saturation.
Limitations
A real bed needs extra length for the mass transfer zone, and heat released on adsorption raises the bed temperature and lowers capacity. Real carbons have uneven surfaces, so other isotherms may fit data better.

Key formulas for absorption vs adsorption

QuantityFormulaSymbols and units
Henry’s lawp_A = H x_Ap_A = solute partial pressure (kPa), x_A = liquid mole fraction, H = Henry’s constant (kPa)
Langmuir isothermq = q_m K p ÷ (1 + K p)q = loading (mol/kg), q_m = monolayer capacity (mol/kg), K = Langmuir constant (kPa⁻¹), p in kPa
Fractional coverageθ = q ÷ q_mθ dimensionless, 0 to 1
Absorber solute balanceG_s (Y_1 − Y_2) = L_s (X_1 − X_2)G_s, L_s = solute free gas and liquid flows (mol/s), Y, X = mole ratios
Adsorbent mass (equilibrium)m = n ÷ qn = solute to be held (mol), m in kg

When to use absorption or adsorption

  • Choose absorption for large gas flows that carry a significant amount of soluble gas, where a solvent can be circulated continuously. Examples are acid gas removal from natural gas and synthesis gas, recovery of ammonia, and control of soluble pollutants in a wet scrubber.
  • Choose adsorption when the impurity is dilute and very low outlet levels are required, or when the target is water vapour or an organic vapour. Examples are drying gases with silica gel, alumina or molecular sieves, solvent vapour recovery on activated carbon, hydrogen purification and air separation by pressure swing adsorption, and activated carbon polishing in the water treatment process.
  • Combine them when a bulk cut by absorption is followed by adsorption for final purification.

Absorbers and strippers share their tray and packing hardware with the distillation column, and the solvent circulation rate comes from the plant material balance. Rich and lean solvent streams are usually cross exchanged in heat exchangers to save stripper steam.

Absorption vs adsorption interview and viva questions

  1. What is the basic difference between absorption and adsorption? Absorption takes the solute into the bulk of the absorbent, while adsorption holds it only on the surface, so adsorption capacity depends on surface area.
  2. Why do industrial adsorbents have high porosity? Nearly all the usable surface lies inside the pores, so a porous structure gives a very large surface per unit mass and therefore a high capacity.
  3. What does the Langmuir isotherm assume? A uniform surface with a fixed number of identical sites, one molecule per site, a single layer and no interaction between adsorbed molecules.
  4. What is breakthrough in a fixed bed adsorber? It is the point when the mass transfer zone reaches the bed outlet and the solute concentration in the outlet starts to rise, signalling that the bed must be regenerated.
  5. How is the solvent from an absorber regenerated? The rich solvent is sent to a stripper, where heat, steam or lower pressure drives the solute out, and the lean solvent is returned to the absorber.

Frequently asked questions

What is sorption?

IUPAC uses sorption as a general term for the uptake of a substance by another when absorption and adsorption occur together or cannot be told apart. Water taken up by a porous solid that both coats the pore walls and fills the pores is a common case.

What is the difference between physisorption and chemisorption?

Physisorption is held by weak intermolecular (van der Waals) forces, is reversible and can build up several molecular layers. Chemisorption forms chemical bonds with surface atoms, is limited to a single layer and releases more heat, so it is often harder to reverse.

Why are gas absorbers operated counter-current?

With gas flowing up and liquid flowing down, the leanest gas meets the freshest solvent at the top and the richest gas meets the most loaded solvent at the bottom. This keeps a concentration driving force along the whole column, so less solvent and a shorter packed height are needed for the same removal.

References

  1. R. E. Treybal, Mass-Transfer Operations, 3rd ed., McGraw-Hill, 1980
  2. W. L. McCabe, J. C. Smith and P. Harriott, Unit Operations of Chemical Engineering, 7th ed., McGraw-Hill, 2005
  3. D. W. Green and M. Z. Southard (eds.), Perry's Chemical Engineers' Handbook, 9th ed., McGraw-Hill, 2019, Sections 14 (Gas absorption) and 16 (Adsorption and ion exchange)
  4. J. D. Seader, E. J. Henley and D. K. Roper, Separation Process Principles, 3rd ed., Wiley, 2011
  5. IUPAC, Compendium of Chemical Terminology (the Gold Book), entries for absorption, adsorption and sorption
  6. M. Thommes et al., Physisorption of gases, with special reference to the evaluation of surface area and pore size distribution (IUPAC Technical Report), Pure and Applied Chemistry 87 (2015) 1051
  7. I. Langmuir, The adsorption of gases on plane surfaces of glass, mica and platinum, Journal of the American Chemical Society 40 (1918) 1361

Get one engineering email a week

New articles, worked examples and study notes every week. Free, no spam, unsubscribe any time.

Zenta Engineering

Articles written by the Zenta Engineering editorial staff are checked by our technical team against the references listed on each page, following our editorial policy. Editorial policy.

Related articles